Dragon House debuted on HBO and fans already remember the show that started it all, Game of thrones. George RR Martin created some fantastic characters in his novels, but Brienne of Tarth has got to be a fan favorite.
Honorable, loyal, powerful and fierce, Brienne has been on quite a journey through Thrones. Despite all of his fantastic qualities, some members of the ever-growing audience voiced their unpopular opinions of the character on Reddit. Whether it’s based on his story, his personality traits, or his interactions with other characters, not everyone will agree on these views.
ten No character development
Brienne de Tarth has come a long way since her first outing in Game of thrones. She’s no longer as naive as she once was, picking up some courage and filth from Westeros that she could only have gained from lived experience. There’s also a consistency to his characterization that’s refreshing.
However, some fans would disagree with this analysis. AnotherBlackMan commented on Brienne in novel form, but that’s for the show as well. They said, “For most of the books, her character is essentially the same. There’s no character development. Brienne has always been and always will be a dumb follower. To top it off, she never really does anything. .”
9 too honorable
Brienne’s honorable nature is one of the most compelling things about the character. It’s one of the things fans love because she’ll always choose the morally right path, no matter how difficult. As one Reddit user mentions, this can be a death sentence in Westeros.
But they go on to say that the personality point is a flaw. Issenet said: “The fact that she is honorable is really a mark against her for me. I feel like her life is a post-dated check, for me anyway. Show the version anyway. Not that ‘she’s different in the books.” This is certainly an opinion with which many would disagree.
8 Brienne’s Thrones Finale
The end of game of thrones was quite controversial. The HBO series went so far outside of the novels, and elements of the narrative didn’t sit well with audiences. For the most part, however, Brienne’s final arc ended well, with most viewers happy with her eventual promotion and semi-happy ending.
A Redditor thought his character was ruined by the show, compared to the books. Mary1AndOnly wrote a detailed but perhaps unpopular article summarizing it, saying, “The crux of the majority of Brienne’s problems on the show is that D&D failed to write her…completely.” changes that D&D made with it.”
seven The wrong cast
Gwendoline Christie is an amazing casting choice for Brienne. She came to understand the character and pulled out all the stops to create a beloved hero and fighter. Christie is easily one of the best performers on the show and captured all the range needed to pull off such a complex character.
But his casting did not please everyone. amara90 said: “I think some aspects of the character have been changed with the casting of Gwendoline Christie. Much of Brienne’s naivety and earnestness is a product of her youth. And when you cast your thirties, it’s impossible to fully capture that. There’s an automatic global weariness for Show Brienne.”
6 Finish with Jaime
Jaime and Brienne’s relationship is a true “will they, won’t they” conundrum that gets into several morally gray territories. They ultimately don’t go together, as deep down Jaime is still selfish, as he eventually proves by returning to his sister and King’s Landing. Eventually, most viewers saw that Brienne was better off without him.
Some are still rooting for the pair. St7e said: “I never thought about it much before but now I desperately want Jaime and Brienne to be happily ever after. I know that probably won’t happen (I think Jaime will die and Brienne will live) but they are both such great characters and such good people that they deserve a happy ending.” It’s an alternative point of view!
5 The Sansa Comparison
Brienne and Sansa have walked similar paths, but their characters couldn’t be more different. There are a wide variety of quotes that sum up each individual and it’s usually clear who said what. They have diverse points of view and any comparison might be more about their arc than their personalities.
Interestingly, a Reddit point is supported by George RR Martin. In a thread, a Reddit user said “She’s Sansa in armor (in GRRM’s words)”, but went on to “in another interview he said he doesn’t remember saying that”. This is certainly a controversial point that is supported by some Redditors but perhaps not by the author.
4 Lack of intelligence
When it comes to the tactical maneuvers of warfare, Brienne is pretty well suited. But she made many smart choices throughout her career as a knight and was one of the few characters to survive the events of Game of thrones. His intelligence should therefore not be taken lightly.
It would be unpopular to say she’s stupid, but kimosfesa remarks that “But, she can just follow orders, those can be very absurd like trying to find a girl she’s never seen. She’s also very dumb, the whole arc of her trying to save Sansa is in my opinion one of the least “realistic” in the series. On top of that, her character has evolved very little over the course of the series. She continues to follow what people want her to do.” Is she stupid to follow orders?
3 Most difficult chapters
Brienne’s chapters in the Song of Ice and Fire saga have become absolute favorites of some readers. They made it to the screen with some precision, and ultimately the combination of TV scripts and source material created the Brienne that mainstream audiences now know.
Just because people love its ups and downs doesn’t mean all readers enjoyed the journey. estemar said: “I found her story very difficult to read, because we knew where Sansa was and she wouldn’t reach it. It made it very difficult to be interested. It gives you an idea of what the war did to people, and what the Crownlands and Riverlands look like, but I felt like I couldn’t really invest myself in his quest.”
2 It’s hard to encourage
Most fans had no problem supporting Brienne of Tarth in her righteous quest. Compared to characters like Daenerys or Tyrion, who have certainly made questionable moves, Brienne is an easy-to-support character who continues to show that there is still good in Westeros.
While that’s the popular consensus, one fan disagrees. One Reddit user said, “It’s hard to cheer her on when she’s so desperately trying to get herself killed. For her character to grow, she has to accept that she’s female and has female feelings. I think chivalrous chivalry is its defense against itself.” There is certainly a lot to question in the statement.
1 The greatest warrior
There are plenty of contenders for who the best fighter in Westeros is. Most pointed out that Jaime Lannister holds the honor, but regardless of the answer, it’s going to be unpopular among some of the game of thrones fandom, since everyone has an opinion on the matter.
Iceberg23 makes the case for Brienne of Tarth saying “Is Brienne of Tarth the greatest living warrior in Westeros? This may become an unpopular opinion but hear me out… Brienne has quite a resume. She defeated Lloras Tyrell, Jaime (although he was chained and weakened), and even Sandor Clegane on the show.That being said, I can’t think of anyone who’s a bigger warrior than her on the Continent.
NEXT: 10 Quotes That Perfectly Summarize Jaime As A Game Of Thrones Character